Jay Cooks Bakery

ABOUT OUR

Bagels

Enjoy the New York classic, without the NY chaos.

From chewy classics like our Plain Bagels to handcrafted specialty items like our Cinnamon Crunch Bagels, we bring the NY chewy bagel to the Northland.

Benefits of Our Bagels

  • Wholesome Ingredients
    We keep it transparent. We try our best to source all organic ingredients, but if that is not possible, we disclaim it on our labels!
  • Fresh, Never Frozen
    Your bagels are baked fresh – actually. No pulling them out of a freezer to thaw and label as “fresh.”
  • Ingredients That Go Bad – in a Good Way
    Unlike your classic bagels that you grab from the store – these bagels are made with fresh, whole ingredients and no nasty preservatives. So eat ‘em up!
  • Hand-Rolled
    We hand-roll every single bagel – so each one comes with its own personality!
  • The NY Secret Ingredient
    We add an ingredient that most bagel shops don’t because of the expense. This wholesome secret ingredient is what gives NY bagels their signature chew – so we refuse to leave it out!

Bagel Size & Quantity Options

We offer our bagels in three options:

  • Singles
    Only offered in the farmstand!
    This is a great way to try out a bagel flavor you have been looking at.
  • Half Dozen (6)
    Perfect for a couple looking to meal prep or a small family.
  • Dozen (12)
    Perfect for a family meal prepping for breakfast, lunch, or dinner!

Ordering Bagels

Ready to enjoy real bagels?

🛒 Order online
📍 Local pickup in Wrenshall, MN
🕗 Choose your pickup day

Shopping Cart